New Year's Eve in the mountains
|
| ana1325. 10. 2010 22:05:39 |
Turbo, it seems a bit inappropriate to throw everything into the same basket and say that all is smoked and drunk.
If people cheer up a little at the end of the year, nothing is wrong with that, especially if they don't drive a car afterwards.
Bivouacs can be interesting too, but much more complicated overall.
I'm sure the forum has people with positive experiences.
Each person decides for themselves how and what. If this kind of New Year's Eve doesn't suit you, turbo, you won't join. As for Santa, I'm sure his greatest gift is to climb into a snowy fairytale, spend a pleasant night, dance a bit, and return to the valley on the snowy landscape.
|
|
|
|
| ana1327. 10. 2010 00:44:47 |
To those who don't like this kind of New Year's Eve in the mountains, I advise to simply ignore the topic, let those who are interested speak up.
With your wise-cracking you're actually discouraging like-minded people from participating. One would think that people going to the mountains are tolerant and cheerful folks - but from this writing here I'd rather say it's more about intolerant grumblers. Get your heads together, only then will you contribute to people happily visiting this forum.
Just courageously come forward with suggestions where for New Year's Eve in the mountains.
|
|
|
|
| IgorZlodej27. 10. 2010 18:31:40 |
I agree with turbo, this topic is more than chewed over and someone always brings it up around the same time. Then a bunch of words, finally snow falls and all high-flying goals stay in the valley.
|
|
|
|
| jprim27. 10. 2010 19:16:37 |
The most apt comment, ...
and all high-flying goals stay in the valley.
LP!
|
|
|
|
| ana1330. 10. 2010 14:13:44 |
oh, all know-it-alls who desperately try to make the forum no longer serve its purpose - unfortunately. You could still get to Komna, even if it dumps 10m over the holidays and you can stay a day longer in the hut.
if you don't have answers that the topic suggests, why not skip it?
zlodej - about chewed topics better not. you're experienced mountaineer, but if we look your mountain range is narrowly focused on Bovec area and a bit over the border, and Triglav you look there then here. about these tours - same ones you write and repeat for years. it would be nice if you'd sometimes write about some new tour.
I am new here and believe me disappointed.....because I thoroughly checked the forum and topics, I realized that many who used to participate simply withdrew and I'm not surprised at all why.
if I were administrator I'd simply delete topics that don't touch the title.otherwise to those who constantly advertise and criticize I advise to open a forum titled praises and criticisms.....
|
|
|
|
| IgorZlodej30. 10. 2010 15:42:05 |
ana13 your New Year's Eve probably interests no one and so think about it yourself and you don't need to hang it on the big bell. Where, when and how much someone goes is an individual's matter and you're not the one to judge about it, especially since there hasn't been any useful description from you yet. You're not either and it's good that you're not the one who would manage this website, but you can make your own, where you'll set your rules about what anyone can post and what they should describe to satisfy you. Please, list what interests you to be described, because obviously you need it, you're probably completely without ideas if you don't even know how you would do New Year's Eve.
|
|
|
|
| MiR30. 10. 2010 16:20:28 |
Dear ana13, this time with your reply to Igor you missed a bit. Obviously you don't know yet that the western Julian Alps are the wildest, most beautiful and also very, very demanding. And Zlodej's descriptions are very well written, so you can excellently "follow" them and climb some peak that seemed unreachable before. Shame he doesn't compile his mountain visits into a guidebook form. Therefore the reproach that his range is narrow is mildly put impudent. Just as Savinja Alps are far for people beyond Vršič, so are the mountains around Bovec far for us on this side. But it's sad that we argue about New Year's Eve. That's an individual's matter and let everyone experience it as they wish. Let's be patient and have a nice time in the mountains or in the valleys. There's enough space for all. Good luck!
|
|
|
|
| velesa30. 10. 2010 16:53:54 |
Oh, ana13, welcome to the forum. But you made a mistake - why did you speak up if you're disappointed with the forum. That's your problem, and many of us who post here are not interested in it at all. It would be simpler if you skipped it. That's what you advise yourself, to skip what's not interesting. But obviously something small interests you after all - if nothing else, to comment others.
Looks like you've already walked all the paths that Igor described, and there aren't few, since you say he repeats.
Otherwise, given that you're "new here up", one would expect you to describe something new.
|
|
|
|
| iskalec30. 10. 2010 17:14:26 |
MIR, what is so very, very demanding in the W. Julians compared to ascents to Prisojnik via Hanzova, Kopiščarjeva, to Jalovec from Kotovo, to Ojstrica via Kopinškova, to Kočna via Kremžarjeva, and even in Karavanks there are similar routes e.g. Stol via north face. Numerous pathless areas in Eastern Julians I don't mention. To be more concrete, ascent to Montaž or Viš didn't seem more demanding to me than Hanzova to Prisojnik. Hanzovo to Mojstrovka I didn't even mention. As for Zlodejevi's descriptions, I often miss a short info how to get to the starting point, especially for approaches to less known valleys and ascents to less known peaks.
|
|
|
|
| kaveljc30. 10. 2010 22:53:44 |
Ana13 and iskalec let me also write a few words... Ana13 if you want to go somewhere just go no problem and enjoy since you probably don't have friends and relatives with whom you want to spend the longest night... inquire in some PD and I believe they will advise you right! iskalec, buy yourself some guidebook and map so you won't underestimate others' achievements on this forum!!! If as you say you've walked numerous pathless areas, then it won't be a problem for you to find starting points for ascents that Igor describes???...as for other routes you mention...they are nice, but nothing else than the most known and maximally secured paths with us that are massively visited...Igor's descriptions are most useful for those seeking more solitary and less visited paths...
|
|
|
|
| potepinka30. 10. 2010 23:36:52 |
Well, ana13, the topic is in the forum section "general talks - debates that don't belong elsewhere" so it's completely realistic to expect that everyone can join the debate and write their opinion on the topic. Positive or negative.
But if you want to find company for New Year's Eve, you can write that in the "together in mountains" section and just say that you want to find someone or a group to join for New Year's Eve and add your expectations about it.
Regarding Igor's trips that are supposed to be all the same, there's nothing wrong with that. They are in the "current conditions" section and they change and many people (I'm sure) find a lot useful in them.
Everyone knows for themselves why they visit this website which we ultimately create together and we can certainly skip contributions that don't "fit" us with one click.
|
|
|
|
| iskalec31. 10. 2010 07:24:05 |
Kaveljc, I don't understand what buying guidebooks has to do with underestimating others' achievements? In my contribution not a single word mentioned any specific underestimation of someone else's achievements. As for guidebooks and maps I have a collection of all guidebooks on our mountains, maps of our and foreign mountains. Book Das grosse ADAC Alpenbuch, Kletersteig Atlas - Alpen and many other books on mountaineering, even fiction. Guidebooks on Bosnian and Montenegrin mountains (the latter I had the opportunity to traverse lengthwise and crosswise in a few years). Wasn't your advice therefore a bit underestimating? I don't understand people who immediately attack someone else's opinion even though they have no information about the person expressing the opinion. No hard feelings.
|
|
|
|
| Otto31. 10. 2010 07:55:50 |
As Vahta wrote in one of the topics it would be good to stick to the topic. But the forum is increasingly leaning towards self-praise and settling scores with those who think differently. Igor's route descriptions and his knowledge of the mountains are really great, but that doesn't give him the right to behave condescendingly towards others on this forum (this is evident from some of his posts where he doesn't answer the question but gives some unnecessary comment). Also Turbot's comments in this topic are not needed (otherwise he has good and noteworthy remarks). If someone likes to celebrate in a hut let him do it and no need to immediately belittle him and label him a drunkard...
And to stick to the topic so I don't contradict the above myself. Almost all huts that are open in winter also on weekends prepare New Year's Eve celebrations. The question is if they don't already have reservations. You can go up alone too since if you're not sulky you'll quickly find company. So phone in hand and inquire in specific huts. As already described: Komna, Koča pod Bogatinom, Dobrča, Kofce, Kriška gora,...
And don't misunderstand me. I also gladly read every good description and listen to every constructive comment.
|
|
|
|
| wolphgang31. 10. 2010 09:15:55 |
Can someone tell what does the number of trips you've entered have to do with participating in the forum? That person is right who says that here you are all know-it-alls and the site is just for self-affirmation. Anyway regarding New Year's Eve, to hell with all abstainers, whether in mountains or valley, I'll cheerfully toast and not with raspberry spirit.
|
|
|
|
| jprim31. 10. 2010 09:21:15 |
And one off-topic!
As I already wrote once but I don't remember under which topic anymore ...
'yeah our youth, it needs to be re-educated', but for some it's long overdue, no offense, where are the values worth respecting in life, where are some ideals, dear our youth ... tolerance, respect for different ones, in your comments I rarely see it.
LP!
|
|
|
|
| JusAvgustin31. 10. 2010 09:28:34 |
In this topic I don't know if there are 5 posts dedicated to the topic...  on Uncle Google there is plenty of info on hut rentals, New Year's Eve in huts, various offers. You just need to google it. Have nice celebrations wherever you will be with whomever you will be on whatever you will be.
|
|
|
|
| IgorZlodej31. 10. 2010 09:59:06 |
Interesting that the biggest "know-it-alls" are those who registered just a few days ago or change name for every post and re-register, which anyone can easily check by viewing the profile of the individual registered. So the name is new but the same stupidities continue. This includes those who haven't managed to post even one picture so far, let alone any useful description, not to mention providing current conditions which are obviously Spanish village to them since most would like everything on a platter and preferably immediately when they post their apt or inept question. As for my repeating descriptions, probably most aren't interested. But I'll stick to the rule that if I can be useful to one I won't look at a hundred others who aren't interested because they are more active, more experienced, broader and know more. In the end I'm surprised that on the page under "Abroad" section I'm a lone rider; if I add those posts I sometimes wrote under nickname "triglavski" I can calmly say it's 90% mine. Now I don't know if you others are so narrow-minded that your view doesn't reach beyond Rateče or you selfishly keep your feats to yourselves and those who know almost everything about everything and everyone and butt in exactly into that about which you so fervently write that it doesn't belong on the forum.
Waiting for opinion of Tadej and Rok if they have it.
|
|
|
|
| bagi31. 10. 2010 10:17:02 |
Igor, you don't need opinion of Tadej and Rok. The whole story is called *Dogs bark, caravan moves on* Whoever regularly reads these forums already knows where to place whom including all one-day flies. You are unique but credible and already kind of inventory of these pages. And you're not the only one anymore. More and more permanent names here contributing their part. The rest as they are ...
LP Bagi
|
|
|
|
| Micky22. 10. 2011 13:09:07 |
Does anyone maybe know which mountain huts will organize New Year's Eve this year? My wife and I would go to welcome the new year somewhere in the mountains this year but I have no data yet on where it will be possible. I believe many of us think similarly
lp
Emil
|
|
|
|
| Otto22. 10. 2011 15:13:22 |
There is almost no hut that is accessible also in winter (mid-mountains) that wouldn't organize New Year's Eve too. Every year they organize New Year's Eve at Dobrča, Kriški Roblek, Komna, Koča pod Bogatinom,... Best to just inquire at some mountaineering club that has a hut up to about 1500 m.
|
|
|
You must log in to post a comment:
If you do not yet have a username, you must first
register.