|
| viharnik16. 09. 2010 19:51:49 |
I agree with you, Gorski svizec! Drunks should stay in the valley, hut masters should rethink their ethics and mission in high mountains over allowing beyond all frames of true mountain atmosphere and order in huts. They should take example from neighboring countries' huts and order, especially house rules, as the mountaineer next day needs a clear head and safe step on tour. The only pleasing thing is that the limited summer season of boozing and revelry in huts is ending, which will benefit the rest of the mountains and the wildlife.
|
|
|
|
| iskalec16. 09. 2010 20:15:53 |
Kredarica really disappointed me on my last visit. I experienced the same atmosphere as described by gorski svizec. I add the stench from the toilet, which spread around the hut. Foreigners who were there then, especially those from neighboring alpine countries, shook their heads. Don't know how the men depicted in the picture and bust in one of the hut rooms, who were also the main organizers of the building and renovation of Kredarica, would view all this???? If this situation continues, I will avoid visiting Kredarica in the future!!! There are plenty of taverns in the valley for tavern partying.
| (+1) |  | |
|
|
|
|
| šerpa16. 09. 2010 22:07:08 |
Some already avoid Kredarica... and similar cash-register and overly pluralistic oriented huts and keepers, who put their original mission second for max profit.
| (+1) |  | |
|
|
|
|
| triglav116. 09. 2010 22:35:54 |
I think PZS or the society managing "mountain hut at Kredarica" should replace the hut keeper next season. The new keeper should take care of order and accordions and send drunks to the valley where they belong. No hard feelings! I myself already avoid Kredarica in a big arc now.
| (+1) |  | |
|
|
|
|
| prahec16. 09. 2010 23:34:25 |
Unfortunately I too avoid ascent to our Father due to very real above description which I experienced. Just because of general popularity of mountain and already shameful conditions in hut at Kredarica. Near Triglav there are couple beautiful mountains still luckily spared from popularity of "valley shouters". Though approach of true mountaineers shrinks unpopulated nature, scares animals and changes their natural cycle and life flow in high mountains over centuries with our visits, latest conditions in Kredarica hut are outright big black spot amid mountain crystals of some civilizational vulgarity. Whose authors certainly not true mountaineers. Dom at Kredarica as hut under highest peak should be example to all other mountain huts in Slovenia, not "boozers' sanctuary". If it's Slovenia's natural park, competent institutions should act. Don't know how it would hit keeper's psyche and pocket if during those night boozing hours, which he equals, probably financially and morally satisfied with self, visited by trade and/or sanitary inspector. In short, shameful situation caused by human factor, for Julian Alps, for mountains, for Triglav, for high mountain poetry..
| (+1) |  | |
|
|
|
|
| EUGEN17. 09. 2010 09:06:13 |
Capitalism has reached mountain huts too (sadly). Most keepers are after profit and just "complain how bad business is". Of course there are exceptions (hut on Planina Kuhinja). Huts have lost their original function which they had for many years. I prefer to avoid huts and enjoy nature. That's my opinion and experience.
|
|
|
|
| klm17. 09. 2010 09:56:42 |
Bravo, I fully agree with Turbo, Eugen and Prahc. The most "packarij" is done by PD Ljubljana-Matica. They actually have the best (most frequented, no mistake) huts they manage, i.e., Kredarica, Hut at Triglav Lakes, Dom on Komna, Hut at Savica, Dom in Kamniška Bistrica. Maybe I missed some. The management of PD is so oriented that it actually thinks quite entrepreneurially, so they are only interested in profit. That's why their huts have unique locations, as Kredarica and Hut at Triglav Lakes are the main stops of the "Triglav Highway", Komna brings them profit in winter, the Dom in Kamniška Bistrica is also a starting point for many hikers, an end point for many pensioners and cyclists, even runners. As a registered mountain hut, the tax is only 8.5% instead of 20!?! Just imagine what profit this one hut brings to the mentioned PD! - More than all inns from Stranje to Bistrica together! I myself have started more or less avoiding such huts, or I visit only those where I feel at home. Otherwise, the hut also represents civilization, which I try to escape for a short time with ascents...
|
|
|
|
| IgorZlodej17. 09. 2010 11:34:12 |
Kredarica is not like that because of the current keeper, but the history is much longer. The big shots in Ljubljana decided long ago that the Triglav Dom on Kredarica must be enlarged and turned into a hotel, and they got support from various sides. Just look how many sponsors participated (all listed on one of the tables in the dining room); here it's mainly about the lobbying skills in PD Lj-Matica, who of course knew that the bigger the hut, the more visitors and more revenue. PZS actually had no influence on this at all or didn't want it, since "Matica" is the society with the most members and why limit it. Also otherwise, a PZS official stated years ago that "Matica" is a state within a state or within PZS, practically untouchable. Kredarica as the largest or highest mountain station is a very convenient goal for crowds of all kinds of hikers. Our discussion and commenting is more or less in vain, because nothing will change because of it. Concrete remarks, if any, should be addressed to the relevant society managing the hut, and to PZS, which of course again won't solve the problems and inconveniences that individuals encounter or maybe after all. Inspectorate services usually don't go that high, especially without concrete notification of irregularities, but I'm sure they don't read such remarks on the forum either and even if they did, they wouldn't serve as a basis for action, at least not yet. Otherwise, you can submit criticisms as well as praises here too: http://www.pzs.si/index.php?stran=Seznam the question is if anyone reads it at all. Personally, regarding Kredarica I have none, especially not off-season.
|
|
|
|
| viharnik17. 09. 2010 12:30:13 |
It's true what Igor mentions regarding sponsorship and PZS, but let me add that the deliberate number of bars and capacities at Kredarica itself is not to blame for the improper behavior of guests during night rest time. The problem is who is the master in the hut and if he himself can ensure the rules of the game and behavior. How will foreigners see us in their eyes (chronicles!) in a few years if the situation doesn't change. I also think that in the whole matter regarding this year's tourist influx to the dom, after so many climbers, there shouldn't be problems and thus additional night operations and serving drinks and causing uproar by a minority. If such a trend continues, then it will become a habit for some self-evident types and the chaotic situation in the dom will only continue. I myself with colleagues sometimes stood behind the bar after ten o'clock, but we were aware and considerate to those who went to rest and didn't make noise.
1
|
|
|
|
| skalar5017. 09. 2010 12:51:07 |
Story about caravan and psyches... (Naive) waiting for the rise of general culture of visitors to Slovenian mountains (huts) or tightening of the rules of the game? Quite interesting how these things are almost self-evident e.g. with our northern and western neighbors while we are still in many places mountaineering (literally) inn-plank-headed... but the current story (I also strongly doubt that despite this forum and new PZS team next year anything will be substantially different), as IgorZ wrote some time ago, moves to winter sleep... the summer season of Sunday tourist assault troops is after all (June 15 - Sept 15) inevitably ending... and peace returns to the mountains again (priceless for many of us)... and pure pleasure...
1
|
|
|
|
| micamaca12. 10. 2010 12:31:45 |
Regarding all the criticisms that flew here at Kredarica, I would say the following: the unpleasant conditions in this hut are a consequence of mass visits especially in summer time and mountain-unaccustomed visitors who come here just to "party". This weekend my boyfriend and I were up there, we slept at Kredarica in sweet peace, the keeper is EXTREMELY friendly and it hurts her when badly spoken about them. I know, not all keepers are pleasant, I've met grumpy ones too, but mostly I've had good experiences everywhere. They are also people, probably in summer even exhausted from the rush and probably shouldn't hold it against them if sometimes due to fatigue they don't have their day. And once again: I would praise the helpfulness and friendliness of both ladies who worked "at the counter" this weekend and the coffee they brewed for us when we returned early from Triglav
|
|
|
|
| skalar5014. 06. 2011 14:56:59 |
huts are slowly opening again for summer...and with them new stories with keepers... maybe despite previous thoughts it would still be worth keeping this rubric "alive" until mid-September (even if PZS site has it). One more option for the people to write their experiences... And thus one more chance that something might stick to someone from PZS tops (read individual societies)...
|
|
|
|
| viharnik14. 06. 2011 18:09:41 |
I think that Slovenian huts have been moving a bit for the better in recent times. Especially in high mountains the catering offer is declining in quality. It's not all good for the mountaineer who comes for a hot meal, like some watery soup with a few floating vegetables on top and sausage from a few years ago, so that in the morning regenerated he goes on the trail. Often in the peak hiking season it happens that keepers literally rip off hikers with double or triple prices of basic goods like bottled water, overnight stays etc. Prices of services and food should be at least partially equalized everywhere, since they are property of PDs and not in private ownership. It also happens that certain huts that sell cow products (sour milk, cheese) these or their PDs limit and take away the right of nearby mountain pastures because of competition to sell dairy products. In mid-mountains where more water is available, mountain huts should also think about introducing showers for every hiker who wants to refresh and get rid of sweat. On mountain paths there are still too few volunteer markacists who would care for passability of paths and marking signs, not to mention winter ones. Keepers should besides announced employment criteria also be mountain lovers and not just people who work up there and complain on the spot that they see only mountains all the time.
|
|
|
|
| GregorC14. 06. 2011 18:29:47 |
Maybe the quality offer really lacks somewhere, but even more true is that people have become too spoiled and would like the same offer and choice somewhere in the mountains as in the city center. Not long ago in a very visited hut where bean stew, jota, one-pot stew and buckwheat mush (and some pastries) were available, someone asked if he could get fries!?! The keeper was so shocked he almost hit the floor with his jaw. I believe improvements could be made somewhere. Personally I've always been satisfied so far and everywhere. Even in some huts criticized here.
|
|
|
|
| viharnik14. 06. 2011 18:41:46 |
We all know there won't be pizza with truffles and artichokes or grilled fish there. The difference is whether the staff cooks the beans well or just throws into the pot whatever they have at the moment which should already be good. The personal approach of the cook to the dish he prepares is important, because more than physical food it's important what vibrations the cook adds or brings into the food, positive or negative.
|
|
|
|
| bperc14. 06. 2011 19:42:22 |
In previous years, prices mainly bothered me, similar to what viharnik already mentioned. If the hut is owned by PD then the price for accommodation, food and drink should be as on the PZS website, not everyone doing their own thing.
|
|
|
|
| Parkeljc15. 06. 2011 08:15:29 |
I don't mean to criticize anyone, I'd just add some of my impressions from visiting the Vittorio Emanuele hut, which is at 2735 m altitude in Italy!!! and is the starting point mainly for the almost pilgrimage path to Gran Paradiso (4061m). Before the visit we of course reserved a 4-bed room. For half-board it was necessary to pay 36 EUR per person. As a PD member it was actually cheaper everything that could be bought in the hut. E.g.: Cappuccino cost 1.- EUR !!! In short, about 30 % cheaper for PD members. WC was clean and tidy, drinking water could be obtained anytime and free, even hot!!, trash cans placed at every step, inside also three for separate waste collection, food and drink served also outside the hut, staff friendly, no need to tidy the room, although we did it out of habit, also for early departure to the summit, no need to pay for the room right away, but only after return from the summit,.. And since I mentioned dinner and breakfast, let me say that they really stuffed us for dinner; for starter choice between vegetable soup and pasta, then main course beef in pieces with stewed vegetables in sauce and for dessert pudding, compote and I don't know what else.. Breakfast classic butter, jam, tea or white coffee.. And all this at height 5m lower than our ŠKRLATICA !!!  
|
|
|
|
| Paintball15. 06. 2011 12:40:53 |
Well well, I also agree that the quality of food could be better somewhere, same with more affordable prices. But by no means do I accept that some expect hotels in the mountains (chambermaids, hot showers, WCs with sewage, trash cans...). We must realize that all wastewater in the mountains must be poured into the environment, thus consequently polluting nature. If a person manages a bit, he quickly finds a solution for such unimportant problems, which in truth arose only with our spoiling. I e.g. in case of overnight take some moist wipes with me, which nicely replace the shower, drinking water I always have in reserve, trash anyway must always be taken down to the valley, where you can sort them as you like
|
|
|
|
| skalar5016. 06. 2011 00:15:02 |
Huts abroad? Comparison with Slovenia? One experience was written a few "posts" ago by "parkeljc"... I myself have quite a few similar experiences (mainly) from Austrian mountains. Do the men (sorry ladies), who run PD really never stray into nearby rocks (huts) also outside the country?
1
|
|
|
|
| viharnik16. 06. 2011 21:50:07 |
Perhaps the most suitable model or example for our hut managers, if they don't see beyond our borders, is precisely Komna. It stands on the border between mid-mountains and high mountains and offers good cuisine, renovated premises, diligent caretaking staff and friendliness, house rules and cleanliness, prices appropriate for the quality of food they prepare and accommodation. With us only high mountains lack, especially around Triglav and also elsewhere in our mountains, where they think that since they are so high, the food can match that. But the rule holds that where there are main hiking trails and crowds of hikers, in huts they don't care much about quality, but more about salty prices, elsewhere with fewer hikers the staff is aware of every visitor and maximally engages in the kitchen and completely different reception. This applies both to Polhograjci and the highest located posts. Because of that then on the way back I rather leave those few € at some good inn in the valley.
|
|
|
You must log in to post a comment:
If you do not yet have a username, you must first
register.